[ Contents | Search | Post | Reply | Next | Previous | Up ]
From: David Shapiro
Date: 14 Oct 2008
Time: 13:45:07 -0500
Remote Name: 72.71.67.203
Hi John, I’m not aware of any data reporting on the effectiveness of a clinician based upon gender alone. So many characteristics must come together in order for a clinician to be effective. These characteristics, among others, include commitment, competence, and compassion. Years ago, Lon Emerick (1974) referred to the interaction between a clinician and a client as the element of “clinical magic.” I think his notion continues to hold relevance, particularly today. The gender of a prospective clinician, however, occasionally is dictated by the cultural traditions and beliefs of the prospective client or the client’s family. You might be interested in a paper I published in 1994 (Tender Gender Issues, in the November issue of Asha), where I addressed your question directly. Good luck. David Shapiro