LOSING YOUR WILL TO SPEAK
By John C. Harrison
Program Director, National Stuttering Project
A couple of years ago my wife and I went to the San Mateo County
Fair south of San Francisco. I've always liked county fairs because I
get to see things a city slicker doesn't bump into very often like cows,
4-H exhibits and working sheep dogs.
Plus there are always a few surprises.
We were just about to leave the fair when announcer on the
loudspeaker over by the main stage announced that noted hypnotist George
Somethingorother was going to start his show in just five minutes. Ever
since I was a kid, I've been fascinated with hypnotists. Doris, too.
So we plunked our butts down on a bench and waited for the show to
The hypnotist was pretty good. He had klutsy teenagers doing
slick Tony Orlando imitations and hulking linebacker types hopping
around the stage like Peter Rabbit. But what I remember best is a big,
strapping motorcyclist, the kind who could play volleyball with my
refrigerator. The hypnotist told him that when he woke him up, he'll be
stuck to his seat. Sure enough, the fellow was awakened, and a few
moments afterward, the hypnotist asked everyone on the stage to stand up
and stretch. They all do except this one poor guy. Although he tried
and tried, he just couldn't lift his butt from the chair. The audience
I suddenly had a flash. Maybe that's what happens when we have a
speech block. We're hypnotized.
"C'mon," I can hear you saying. "I stutter and nobody has ever
put me in a trance."
Not so fast. Let's look at how we go about hypnotizing someone.
It calls for getting the subject's complete confidence and trust. We
get him to focus totally on what we're saying, and at some point his
concentration is so focused that he loses his sense of self. Our voice
is his only reality. At this moment he WANTS to believe whatever we
tell him, even if it contradicts his own experience.
Any of this sound familiar? It should. It's similar to how
children are "hypnotized" by adults. Like the hypnotic subject, the
child is extremely impressionable. He perceives the adult as an
authority figure, someone who knows The Truth. He wants to trust and
please. And he wants the adult to take care of him. Consequently, he
is inclined to believe as truth what the adult tells him...whether it's
true or not.
Voila! Hypnosis without the trance.
These post-hypnotic suggestions from childhood are carried into
adult life and control the way we feel and act. Obviously, a great deal
of what our parents tell us is necessary if we are to become socialized
and well-adjusted. But sometimes a well-meaning parent or other
authority figure gives us suggestions that are not in our best
interests; for example, good children "should be seen and not heard,"
good children shouldn't cry or get angry or want what they want, etc.
These suggestions separate us from what we truly think and feel and if
left unchallenged, serve as guidelines for our entire lives.
LOSING THE EXPERIENCE OF BEING IN CONTROL
But why don't we know we're hypnotized? Easy. We forget where
our beliefs come from.
Over time, we have come to believe that the compulsion to be nice,
to hold in our feelings, to speak perfectly, to always satisfy other
people's needs at the expense of our own are all things we really want.
We forget that we're following someone else's commands. So when we go
to express our true desires...like asking someone in a non-smoking
section to put out his cigarette...we block and we don't know why.
See how similar in concept this is to the motorcyclist in the
hypnosis demonstration? You tell him he won't be able to unstick
himself from his chair. You also tell him to forget all knowledge of
what has just transpired. Then you wake him up and ask him to stand up
and stretch. Try as he will he can't get up.
On one hand he does want to stand up. That's his own will
asserting itself. Yet, on a deeper level, he really doesn't want to
stand up. He wants to follow your directions to the letter. He wants
to please you. Your will is more important than his. The only reason
his inability to rise seems like voodoo to him is that you've previously
told him to forget all knowledge of the suggestions you've given him.
He doesn't know that he's the one who's choosing to stay seated.
Let's look at this in terms of speech blocks. Have you ever
noticed that whenever you block, you seem to be pulled in two directions
-- to talk and not to talk? That's not very far removed from wanting to
stand and sit and the same time. You want to do two opposing things,
and it leaves you frozen and unable to move.
But that's silly. Why wouldn't you want to talk?
When your lips are locked and you can't say "butter" to the lady
in the cafeteria, it could be that you're acting off an internalized,
unspoken directive that says you shouldn't be assertive. Or as a child
you may have picked up the belief that every word that came out of your
mouth had to be perfect. It could be any number of different reasons.
Your inability to speak could also relate to the FEELINGS
associated with the words you want to say. If the serving lady looks
like your hated sixth grade teacher, and you're operating off a
suggestion that it's not "right" to express (or even feel!) anger or
some other strong emotion, you're caught in that same do/don't-do
situation. You want to talk at the same time that you're afraid of
revealing what's really going on. It doesn't feel safe. Consequently,
one inner voice says, "Oops, we better close up shop until it feels less
dangerous." while the opposing voice cries out, "But...but I gotta say
this RIGHT NOW!"
You're in a similar situation to the biker who can't get out of
his seat. You want to do something, yet at the same time you're acting
off of a belief (implanted years ago) that says you shouldn't...a
prohibition that you've totally forgotten about. This theory of
conflicting intentions explains why 99% of us can talk just fine when
we're alone and not likely to be confronted with opposing demands.
The actual "hypnotic suggestion" is hard to pinpoint. The only
point I want to make is that when you're trying to speak and not speak
at the same time, it's as if you've been hypnotized.
WE'RE CONSTANTLY BEING HYPNOTIZED
Most of us don't recognize the degree to which we are constantly
being "hypnotized" by suggestions from the media, our business
associates, our friends and loved ones. Here's a typical example.
You're out shopping with a close friend whose opinion you trust.
In the sportswear department of Macy's your friend finds a shirt she
says would look just great on you. At first, you don't like it. Not
your colors. But the more she talks, the more you begin to come around,
until you suddenly decide you like it and buy the shirt. You've been
hypnotized. You're foregoing your own experience and seeing something
you don't really see.
We've looked at how other people's suggestions can effect our
perceptions. Let me demonstrate the way in which suggestions can affect
us physically. Let's say you're on a connecting flight from Pittsburgh
to Williamsport, Pennsylvania, and 30 minutes into the trip you need to
pee in the worst way. It's a dire emergency, because, like many small
commuter aircraft, there is no bathroom on board. (I've been on that
flight; I know.) Your seat mate (of the same sex) jokingly suggests
that in an emergency you could use the airsickness bag to pee in. (I'm
assuming you're a guy.)
Would you do it if you had to?
If you're like the rest of us, you'd rather die first. Our
parents, those early childhood hypnotists, gave us repeated prohibitions
about peeing anywhere other than in the john or behind a bush. Those
proscriptions are so strong that they allow us to perform amazing feats
of self-control, which is why you're able to hang on.
At last, the plane lands. As you race through the terminal toward
the john, you notice something curious. The need to pee and the fear
that you won't make it increases in direct proportion to how close you
are to the john. The closer you get, the more you feel like you're
losing control. As you frantically unzip your jeans, the last three
seconds are sheer hell. But you make it...just.
You were on the flight for almost an hour. Could it be that you
actually timed it down to the last critical second? Highly unlikely.
You're simply experiencing how your unconscious programming causes you
to lock and unlock your sphincter.
Your resolve not to pee weakened the closer you got to the john,
because you knew that in a moment it would be socially acceptable to let
go. This is why you unconsciously started to relax control of your
sphincter and why it suddenly felt that you couldn't wait a second
longer. IT ONLY SEEMED LIKE YOU HAD SPLIT SECOND TIMING BECAUSE
THE WHOLE LOCKING/UNLOCKING PROCESS TOOK PLACE OUTSIDE YOUR
From my observation, this is similar to what happens with a speech
block. We unconsciously lock our speech muscles when it seems
threatening to express ourselves, and we don't allow those muscles to
release until the intensity of our feelings subsides, and it feels safe
to talk again. No matter how hard we try to force out the words, our
will to hold back is stronger.
As you can see, then, other people's suggestions can exert
powerful controls over our thoughts, feelings and behavior. Let's sum
up our observations about hypnosis and stuttering.
- Someone can hypnotize you without putting you in a trance. You
are hypnotized when someone else's reality becomes more "real" than your
-- When a hypnotic suggestion comes in conflict with something you
want to do, you will become blocked. Being blocked is a conflict of
will--yours and someone else's.
-- A post-hypnotic suggestion is nothing more than taking on the
other person's will and making it more powerful than your own. Be
perfectly clear that this does not happen to you. You CHOOSE to believe
the other person and give him or her this power.
-- A speech block may represent the same kind of conflict as that
experienced by the motorcyclist who couldn't get out of his seat. There
is an unconscious command not to do something.
-- What we call chronic stuttering (or speech blocks) may really
be struggle behavior in which we try to push out a word which, at that
moment, we don't want to say.
-- There are any number of reasons why we might not want to say
that word. The reasons can relate to particular emotions associated
with that word, emotions that we're afraid to show, or we might be
afraid to speak up because of how we might appear to others.
-- We usually don't know when we're hypnotized. Therefore, we're
likely to do things, or be blocked from doing them, and not understand
why. Because we've forgotten that we've made all the original choices,
the block appears to be outside of our control, and we feel helpless.
-- We cannot be hypnotized without first having a NEED to believe.
There can be many reasons for this need, such as wanting another
person's approval or love, being afraid to act forcefully in the
presence of an authority figure, believing that the other person's
reality is more "real" than our own, etc.
-- Hypnosis involves a loss of will, and in the case of speech
blocks, it can involve losing our will to speak.
If all of the above is true, then how can we un-hypnotize
Doing it takes hard work. The concept is simple, but doing it
takes time, effort and commitment. It calls for reversing the process.
If being hypnotized is a loss of will, then becoming "awake" requires
you to discover what is truly going on and reclaim your will.
You need to begin getting in touch with what is TRUE for you,
rather than what you imagine others want you to believe or feel. Notice
your actions, opinions, feelings. Through extended observation, you may
discover that your speech blocks reflect a conflict between two powerful
Your belief to submit to the will of others.
And your desire to speak your mind and express your true feelings.